Nonprofits Seek OCIOs to Bridge Complexity: CAPTRUST Survey
It’s no surprise that nonprofit organizations are trying to do more with less. They face fundraising uncertainty, tighter budgets, and limited internal resources in an investment environment demanding greater sophistication. To continue fulfilling their missions, organizations must balance near-term spending needs with long-term return objectives, while managing increasingly complex portfolios and investment mandates.
For many organizations, these demands are outpacing their internal resources and expertise. In response, a growing number are turning to OCIO services for hands-on portfolio management, additional investment expertise, and timely decision-making aligned with their mission, values, and long-term objectives.
How Are Nonprofits Using OCIOs?
OCIO utilization is on the rise. CAPTRUST’s 2026 Endowment and Foundation Survey found that organizations with OCIO relationships increased to 44 percent in 2025, up 12 percent from the previous year.
Respondents cited a range of factors behind the decision to use an OCIO including access to investment expertise and private markets experience, reduced administrative burdens, cost considerations, resource limitations, and governance needs.
Among organizations using OCIO services, the most commonly used services include:
- Strategic and tactical asset allocation | 73 percent
- Manager selection and retention | 70 percent
- Capital call management for private investments | 43 percent
- Private market administration | 43 percent
- Cash flow management | 27 percent
The decision to outsource, however, is ultimately a resource-allocation decision. Organizations must consider not only what an OCIO can take on, but also what additional capacity or value that investment creates.
“Any time an organization is considering where to spend assets, it’s important to think about it in terms of a return on investment,” says Grant Verhaeghe, CAPTRUST’s senior director for institutional portfolios, in a webinar highlighting the survey’s results. “You should only spend where you will get a return. I would define that based on impact, fundraising, or efficiency.”
Sophisticated Strategies
Another factor contributing to the demand for investment expertise is the growing role of private markets. As nonprofits increase allocations to private investments, they must also manage the additional complexity, liquidity constraints, and administrative demands these strategies introduce.
Twenty-four percent of respondents to the CAPTRUST survey expect to change their private alternatives allocation in the coming year, with nearly three-quarters of that group planning an increase.
- On the rise: Seventy-eight percent of respondents increased allocations to private equity in 2025, up 12 percent from the previous year, with an additional 10 percent adding to private credit during the same period.
- Hitting pause: Investments in hedge funds, funds of funds, and real assets, including private infrastructure and real estate, declined last year.
- Looking to exit: Three-quarters of respondents expect to decrease their allocation to public real estate this year.
“Organizations are looking to improve returns, outpace inflation, and reduce the risk of correlated assets in their public equity and fixed-income portfolios,” says Verhaeghe. “They are trying to create a smoother return pattern, and ultimately a more predictable spending pattern.”
But pursuing those goals through private markets comes with trade-offs. Unlike public investments, private assets can require multi-year commitments, careful liquidity planning, and ongoing management of capital calls and distributions.
“Once you start an alternatives program, you can’t just turn it off tomorrow, especially if you’re dealing with complicated limited partners and drawdown vehicles,” says Chris Krakowski, a financial advisor at CAPTRUST working with endowments and foundations.
Resources for the Mission
Limited internal resources are weighing on organizations, with survey respondents citing overall staff capacity and risk of burnout among their highest operational concerns. Those pressures can push important governance practices, including stress testing and fiduciary training for board, finance, and investment committee members, further down the priority list.
The objective for an OCIO relationship isn’t outsourcing for its own sake. It’s freeing an organization to focus time, staff, and expertise on where they matter most. Delegating day-to-day investment responsibilities can create capacity for internal teams and boards to focus on oversight, governance, and the decisions most closely tied to the organization’s mission.
“This is a good opportunity to take a step back, and stress test assumptions built into your portfolio, and liquidity,” says Krakowski.
For organizations with limited internal resources, that division of responsibilities can provide access to specialized investment capabilities while allowing staff and board members to remain focused on the areas where their involvement matters most.
For organizations considering an OCIO, the decision ultimately comes down to more than investment performance. Organizations must consider the expertise, capacity, governance support, and flexibility they need to manage increasingly complex portfolios while continuing to meet spending needs and pursue their missions. The right model will differ by organization, but the goal remains the same: placing limited resources where they can have the greatest impact.
Interested in learning more about the 2026 Endowment and Foundation Survey? Here’s a link to our webinar highlighting the findings.
The survey was fielded in 2026 and included 144 organizations, including operating nonprofits, community and private foundations, higher education institutions, and faith-based groups managing assets ranging from less than $25 million to more than $100 million.
Investment advisory services offered by CapFinancial Partners, LLC (“CAPTRUST” or “CAPTRUST Financial Advisors”), an investment advisor registered under The Investment Advisers Act of 1940.